I look back at what introduced me to anime, and quite frankly, I need a paper bag. Thing is, I haven't decided what to do with it. Vomit profusely into it, when I think about what I used to think was awesome? Wear it over my head in shame? Or get it wet and see if the creators of those shows could create meaningful anime to a level that would permeate said sack?
Now, I know. I started with DBZ, and Akira Toriyama is by no means an amateur. Nor is Yoshiyuki "Kill 'Em All" Tomino just because of the existance of tripe like Gundam Wing. But I can't ignore how horribly shallow either of those shows are as a whole.
Wing is especially insipid. Yeah, I liked it at the time, but it was also the 2nd Anime that I watched religiously, and the first moment I saw was literally the series' best. It's not completely useless, as some characters fucked around and actually ended up showcasing depth and backstory (Duo Maxwell). But looking back on it after getting a few more anime viewings under my belt, I see Gundam Wing for what it is: A writer's nightmare.
Studies show that 4 out of 5 Wing pilots are 1-dimensional teenage asshats.
Sans Duo and maybe one or two other people, the character development in Wing is, in a word,
ass. Heero Yuy and Trowa Barton are basically bad echoes of each other; one has no character at all, the other has no emotion. Wufei and Quatre have development, but can be summarized succinctly with adjective/noun compounds. Wufei? Jingoistic prick. Quatre? Mopey downer.
You also have the Gundam trademarks - guy in mask and idealistic leader who can't get anybody useful to follow his ideals. In other words, you've largely seen this before.
Then there's the female cast. Lucrezia "Don't use my first name" Noin, whose dialogue consists largely of "Zechs! No!", as if that Char Aznable wannabe were her dog and were about to piss on her rug. Lady Une starts out awesome and then becomes only slightly more meaningful than the show's truly useless character: Relena Peacecraft, a perpetual (and at this point, professional) hostage. I'll spare you the sermon on her, but let's just say that she makes Gundam 0083's Nina Purpleton look like Revy from Black Lagoon.
And of course, you have the Gundams, which in this case, start out taking some damage and evolve into godlike monoliths of technology. By the time you get to watching the Gundam Wing Movie (Endless Waltz), these things are invincible in ways only bested by Wolverine, who survived being thrown headlong into the sun. Even worse, the designs, while pretty, made no sense. I don't care if you're in an AU series or a UC series,
your Gundam should not fucking molt.
I'm sure those useless-in-space wings are purely tactical. What is this, Air?So, I decided to check out some of the other AU series to see if I can rinse the taste out of my mouth. After playing a little Gundam Vs. Gundam on my PSP, I became intrigued enough to check out After War: Gundam X.
And what an improvement it was.
Don't let the fanny pack fool you. THIS 15 year old is f'n awesome.
I don't want to spoil it to much, because you really need to see it for yourself, but it does so much right. The only complaint I can register thus far is that the arc structure and pacing are a little odd. Story arcs have very clearly defined ends, but since many are very short (4-5 eps per), it can seem somewhat sudden when it's time to move on to a new one.
However, the story here is excellent. In a "What if...?" take on one of the most prevalent horrors of the UC storyline, this one actually takes place after ALL the colonies in space get dropped on earth, killing off 90% of the planet's population. Thankfully, this story is written well enough to properly showcase a post-apocalyptic world in the Gundam universe without going into the same territory as say, for instance, Hokuto No Ken. Things are bad on earth, but it's not Thunderdome yet; instead, people are trying to cope and live under these circumstances.
Character development is awesome in this series, especially considering it's largely working with character types that we've seen before in other Gundam series. Garrod Ran is yet another teenage Gundam Pilot, but he's a believable 15 year old who's had to grow up somewhat quickly. Unlike the emotionless Heero Yuy or the angst-ridden Amuro Ray, Garrod's character gains dimension and depth because his character actually changes over time in response to the world he inhabits. He adapts, and in the event that he is a knucklehead, it's believeable because of his age and he ends up learning from it.
This is really about as tender a moment as these two share.
That quality of extra dimension permeates throughout the rest of the cast. None of the characters in this series end the same way they started, and yet everbody plays their role. I can't think of anybody in this series I really could do without- it's that well written. The plot, by Gundam standards, is very plausible and explained well enough over time to keep you hooked. Even the love story, which is where most UC stories get sappy and maudlin, is done well enough that it doesn't intrude into what's going on.
But what really helps drive this series home is that there are rules to this universe. While Gundams are still the top of the food chain, they are very much vulnerable. Further, none of the pilots are perfect, and that ends up affecting the situations they find themselves in. Air Master, for instance, is not seaworthy- this actually makes a difference. One pilot is a manufactured newtype, and that comes into play in many ways during his battle. There are no gods here- just Gundams and pilots, strenghts and weaknesses. Even the "mega" weapons have limitations, and while I'm usually against such things even existing since they almost always lead to David V. Goliath, it's another story element done well enough that it doesn't water down the overall product.
So, why compare it to Wing? Well, I'll be honest. It's kind of a grudge thing. See, Gundam X was cut short so that Tomino could focus on Endless Waltz. The series still got an ending, but you can tell that it was kind of getting rushed. Between the two series, Wing got the huge fanbase, the movie, and metric tons of merchandise including dozens of wallscrolls. Meanwhile, Gundam X gets chastised because it got cancelled and I'm currently in possession of a copy of the one wallscroll design they make for the series.
Hopefully, this is starting to turn around. Garrod, Tiffa and the GX are starting to appear in more and more games, and word's getting around that this is a great series. And it is. Look, I understand that between Gundam Wing and Gundam Seed, we're probably going to have to deal with teeny-boppers piloting these things at one point or another. But between Garrod Ran, Heero Yuy and Kira Yamato, I'll take the "oldtype" that can hijack a mobile suit with a 9mm.
Final Verdict: Every review I've read of this Anime has very minor complaints
at best. There's a reason for that. Watch it, enjoy it.